Shetland Sheepdog vs. Collie: Key Differences in Herding Breeds

The Shetland Sheepdog and Collie share a rich herding heritage rooted in Scotland. These breeds developed to assist farmers in managing livestock, a task that shaped their intelligence and work ethic. But there’s many more to these dogs than this — let’s explore the similarities and differences between these breeds.

If you’re still on the market to buy a Shetland Sheepdog or Collie, PuppySpot currently offers a $300 discount using the code PUPPY300, just click the banner below!

Physical Characteristics

Collies and Shetland Sheepdogs have distinct physical traits that set them apart. Their size, coat, and facial features are key areas where these breeds differ.

Size and Stature

• Collies are larger than Shetland Sheepdogs. Rough Collies stand 22-24 inches tall at the shoulder for females and 24-26 inches for males. They weigh between 50-75 pounds.
• Shetland Sheepdogs, often called Shelties, are much smaller. They typically measure 13-16 inches at the shoulder and weigh 15-25 pounds.
• This size difference is one of the most obvious ways to tell these breeds apart. Collies have a more robust build, while Shelties have a more delicate frame.

Coat and Colors

Both breeds have double coats, but there are differences in texture and color options.

Collie coat colors:

• Sable and white
• Tri-color (black, white, and tan)
• Blue merle
• White

Sheltie coat colors:

• Sable and white
• Tri-color
• Blue merle
• Bi-black (black and white)

Collies often have a rougher outer coat, while Shelties tend to have a softer, fluffier coat. Both breeds shed seasonally and need regular grooming.

Distinct Facial Features

The facial features of Collies and Shelties show clear differences:

Collie face:

• Long, refined muzzle
• Almond-shaped eyes
• Ears that are partly erect and partly folded

Sheltie face:

• Shorter, more wedge-shaped muzzle
• Rounded eyes
• Smaller, more pointed ears

Both breeds can be affected by collie eye anomaly, a genetic condition. This condition is more common in Collies than in Shelties. Collies have a more pronounced stop (the transition from forehead to muzzle), while Shelties have a smoother profile. These facial differences give each breed its unique expression.

Temperament and Behavior

Shetland Sheepdogs and Collies are smart, loyal dogs with high energy levels. They make great family pets due to their loving nature, but they need plenty of exercise and mental challenges.

Intelligence and Trainability

• Collies and Shetland Sheepdogs are very intelligent breeds. They pick up new commands quickly and excel in obedience training. Both breeds have strong problem-solving skills and enjoy learning new tasks.
• Shelties tend to be more sensitive and may need gentler training methods. Collies are often more confident and can handle firmer corrections. Both breeds respond well to positive reinforcement techniques.
• These dogs thrive on mental stimulation. Puzzle toys, agility courses, and advanced obedience work help keep their minds sharp. Without enough mental exercise, they may become bored and destructive.

Energy and Exercise Needs

• Shelties and Collies have high energy levels and need daily exercise. A brisk 30-60 minute walk plus playtime is ideal for most dogs of these breeds.
• Shetland Sheepdogs are smaller and may tire out faster than Collies. However, they still need regular activity to stay healthy and happy. Fetch, frisbee, and agility are great ways to burn energy.
• Collies have more stamina and can handle longer walks or hikes. They excel at dog sports like herding trials. Both breeds enjoy having a job to do, whether it’s carrying a backpack on walks or helping with household chores.

Barking and Vocalization

• Both Shelties and Collies tend to be vocal breeds. They may bark to alert their owners to visitors or unusual sounds. Shelties are often more prone to excessive barking than Collies.
• Early training can help control barking habits. Teaching a “quiet” command is useful for both breeds. Providing enough mental and physical stimulation also reduces problem barking.
• Shetland Sheepdogs have a distinctive high-pitched bark. Collies typically have a deeper, less piercing bark. Both breeds may also whine or “talk” to their owners when seeking attention or treats.

Training and Mental Stimulation

Collies and Shetland Sheepdogs are smart breeds that need lots of training and mental exercise. They love to learn and do well in many dog activities.

Obedience and Agility

• Collies and Shetland Sheepdogs excel in obedience and agility. They are quick learners and eager to please their owners. Positive reinforcement works best for training these breeds.
• Obedience training helps them learn basic commands and good manners. Both breeds often do well in obedience competitions.
• Agility training is great for their active minds and bodies. They enjoy running through obstacle courses and following their handler’s cues. Many Collies and Shelties compete in agility events.
• Regular training sessions keep these dogs happy and well-behaved. It’s important to start training early and be consistent.

Herding and Working Abilities

• Collies and Shelties were bred as herding dogs. They have strong instincts to gather and move animals.
• Herding training lets them use their natural skills. They can learn to herd sheep, ducks, or cattle. Some owners teach them to herd for fun or for competitions.
• These breeds also make good working dogs in other roles. They can be trained for search and rescue, drug detection, or as assistance dogs.
• Their sharp minds and willingness to work make them versatile. They need jobs or activities to stay busy and content.

Socialization and Therapy Roles

• Early socialization is key for Collies and Shelties. It helps them feel comfortable in different situations.
• These breeds can be shy with strangers. Regular positive experiences with new people and places helps build their confidence.
• Both Collies and Shelties can make great therapy dogs. Their gentle nature and soft fur make them good for comforting people.
• Therapy work gives them mental stimulation and a sense of purpose. It also helps them practice their social skills.
• These dogs thrive on human interaction. Involving them in family activities and outings keeps them happy and well-adjusted.

Health and Lifespan

Collies and Shetland Sheepdogs share some health concerns but differ in others. Both breeds have similar lifespans, ranging from 12 to 14 years. Regular vet check-ups and proper care can help these dogs live long, healthy lives.

Common Health Issues

• Hip dysplasia affects both Collies and Shelties. This condition can cause pain and mobility issues. Progressive retinal atrophy is another shared concern, potentially leading to vision loss.
• Hypothyroidism is more common in Collies. This hormonal imbalance can cause weight gain and skin problems. Shelties may be prone to von Willebrand’s disease, a blood clotting disorder.
• Both breeds can develop eye problems like collie eye anomaly. Regular eye exams are important for early detection and treatment.

Preventative Healthcare

• Proper nutrition is key for both breeds. A balanced diet helps maintain a healthy weight and supports overall health. Regular exercise keeps them fit and mentally stimulated.
• Grooming is crucial, especially for Rough Collies. Brushing their long coats prevents matting and skin issues. Shelties also need regular brushing but have less demanding coats.
• Dental care is important for both breeds. Regular teeth brushing and dental check-ups help prevent gum disease.
• Vaccinations and parasite prevention are essential. These protect against common diseases and parasites that can affect herding breeds.

Genetic Conditions

• Dermatomyositis is a genetic skin condition more common in Collies. It causes skin lesions and muscle inflammation. Careful breeding practices can help reduce its occurrence.
• Collie eye anomaly is inherited in both breeds. It can cause vision problems of varying severity. Genetic testing can identify carriers before breeding.
• Multidrug resistance (MDR1) gene mutation is more prevalent in Collies. This can make them sensitive to certain medications. Genetic testing can identify affected dogs.
• Both breeds may develop thyroid issues. Regular blood tests can detect these problems early, allowing for prompt treatment.

Grooming and Care

Shelties and Collies have different grooming and care needs. Their coats, nutrition, and exercise requirements vary in important ways that owners should understand.

Daily Grooming Requirements

• Shelties and Collies both have thick double coats that shed regularly. Brushing is essential for both breeds to prevent matting and remove loose fur.
• Shelties need brushing 2-3 times a week. Their smaller size makes grooming quicker.
• Collies require brushing 3-4 times weekly due to their larger coat. Special attention to the fur behind their ears and legs prevents tangles.
• Both breeds benefit from monthly baths. Regular nail trims and teeth cleaning are also important.
• Professional grooming every 6-8 weeks helps maintain coat health for both Shelties and Collies.

Nutritional Needs

• Shelties and Collies have different nutritional needs based on their size and activity levels.
• Shelties typically need 1-1.5 cups of high-quality dog food daily, split into two meals.
• Collies require 2-3 cups of food per day, also divided into two meals.
• Both breeds benefit from food rich in protein and healthy fats. Omega-3 fatty acids support their coat health.
• Adjust portions based on age, weight, and activity level. Avoid overfeeding to prevent obesity.
• Fresh water should always be available for both breeds.

Exercise and Activity Recommendations

• Collies and Shelties are active breeds that need regular exercise for physical and mental health.
• Shelties need 30-60 minutes of exercise daily. They enjoy walks, runs, and agility training.
• Collies require 1-2 hours of daily activity. Long walks, jogging, and fetch are great options.
• Both breeds excel at dog sports like flyball and agility. These activities provide mental stimulation.
• Herding activities tap into their natural instincts and provide excellent exercise.
• Puzzle toys and training sessions help meet their need for mental stimulation.
• Regular exercise prevents boredom and destructive behaviors in both breeds.