Sundays vs. The Farmer’s Dog: What’s The Best Dog Food Delivery Service?

Whether you just got a dog or have had one for years and are prioritizing nutrition, there’s a lot of research into what food to buy. It’s an important decision, because the best dog food delivery service can make feeding your furry friend a lot easier.

Most dog food delivery services sell fresh food, which has some major benefits over store-bought kibble. For one thing, inexpensive kibble may be filled with additives, preservatives, chicken meal and other ingredients that aren’t very healthy or natural. Picking the right dog food delivery service ensures that you’ll be feeding your pet nutritious, healthy and complete meals.

Two popular dog food delivery services are Sundays for Dogs and The Farmer’s Dog. Which is the best dog food delivery service?

Five Qualities to Look for in a Dog Food Delivery Service

When you research dog food delivery services, there are a few things to look for. Don’t just pick the least expensive option — there may be quality reasons for the lower price tag. Here are five qualities to look for in a dog food delivery service.

1. Quality of Ingredients

Pay close attention to the quality and transparency of the ingredients in a dog food delivery service meal.

• The food should be made from high-quality ingredients that are human grade.
• Look for brands that prioritize using real organ and muscle meat, whole grains and healthy vegetables.
• Dog food that has natural sources of vitamins and minerals are better.
• Avoid dog food that use fillers like corn, soy and artificial additives and preservatives.

2. Personalization and Variety

When you choose your dog food delivery service, look for brands that give you a high degree of personalization. No two dogs are exactly alike; they should eat the exact same thing either.

• The best dog food delivery services offer food that’s based on your dog’s specific needs.
• Some of the factors that affect the meal service includes age, breed, size and dietary restrictions.
• The dog food delivery service should provide a variety of formulas based on health requirements that your dog has (like allergies, heart problems).

3. Convenience and Reliability

Dog food delivery services should always be reliable. There should be consistent delivery schedules on which you can depend.

• If the dog food delivery is unreliable, you may not get your food on time.
• That means you may need to run to the store and purchase an alternative — this can be hard on a doggo’s stomach.
• The best dog food delivery service has options that accommodate your needs and your dog’s feeding schedule.

4. Transparency and Accountability

Another important factor is transparency and accountability when it comes to manufacturing, packaging and ingredients.

• Choose a dog food delivery service that’s transparent about where they source ingredients.
• It’s also important to be able to know how the food is prepared and stored.
• AAFCO compliance is an important guideline for the quality of the food.
• Look for clear information about nutritional content in feeding guidelines — some dog food brands are able to work around transparency laws.

5. Customer Reviews and Support

If a dog food delivery service is reputable and has strong reviews from previous customers, that’s obviously a good sign.

Background on The Farmer’s Dog

Founded in 2014 by Brett Podolsky and Jonathan Regev, The Farmer’s Dog was launched with the goal of improving the quality of dog food. The catalyst was Brett’s dog, Jada, who had been experiencing severe digestive issues. So what happened next?

With the help of veterinarians, he formulated a home-cooked, human-grade food that quickly helped ease Jada’s digestion issues. He decided that this fresh, delicious and nutritious food should be shared with all dog owners, leading to the founding of The Farmer’s Dog with Jonathan.

• The Farmer’s Dog is based on pet nutrition research that has been compiled over decades.
• They work with the best pet nutritionists and veterinarians on an ongoing basis.
• The company only sells human-grade food that’s nutritionally balanced.
• More than 100,000,000 meals have been delivered by The Farmer’s Dog.
• The Farmer’s Dog starts at $2 a day for small dogs.

The Farmer’s Dog Pros and Cons

Pros

• High-Quality Ingredients: The Farmer’s Dog uses fresh, human-grade meat and vegetables. It is also free from by-products and preservatives, and uses no chicken meals, which can be sourced from diseased animals.
• Customized Meal Plans: One of their signature goals is that The Farmer’s Dog tailors meals based on your dog’s age, breed, size and specific dietary needs. It also provides pre-portioned meals.
• Fantastic Health Benefits: Every single recipe is approved by vet nutritionists. They are also balanced and complete, with dogs experiencing better digestion, shinier coats and healthier skin. And yes, smaller, less messy poops due to better nutrient absorption.
• Convenience: The Farmer’s Dog has regularly scheduled deliveries to your doorstep, which means you don’t have to worry about rushing to the grocery store when you run out of dog food.
• Transparency: The dog food company lists all ingredients and nutritional information and provides information on the foods’ sources.
• Eco-Friendliness: The Farmer’s Dog uses recyclable and eco-friendly materials for packaging. They are also committed to being sustainable.

Cons

• Cost: The Farmer’s Dog is more expensive than traditional dog food brands that you can buy at the supermarket. To get their meals, you must get a subscription.
• Storage Requirements: All meals require refrigeration, which means if you have limited fridge and freezer space, it will be a problem.

Why We Love The Farmer’s Dog

It’s easy to love The Farmer’s Dog. We have looked at countless dog food subscription services and have seen, time and time again, that The Farmer’s Dog strives for excellence. They have earned widespread recognition for its commitment to high quality, human-grade ingredients. That means that every dog under their meal plans receives the nutrition and balance required to live a healthy life.

Their meal plans are also tailored to each dog’s unique needs and preferences — providing a personalized approach to pet nutrition. Each meal is also proportioned and ready to serve. They deliver the meals each week right to your doorstep, which simplifies feeding routines and ensures consistency. You don’t have to worry about going to the supermarket when you run out of dog food.

Background on Sundays for Dogs

Every person, every business and every character has an origin story. The origin story for Sundays for Dogs is, in fact, very similar to The Farmer’s Dog. It all started when the Waxmans’ dog got sick. Dr. Tory Waxman, who is a veterinarian, and Michael Waxman, an engineer, searched day in and day out for the dog food. They wanted something healthier than the store-bought kibble you find on supermarket shelves. When they couldn’t find it, they decided to make it.

Sundays for Dogs Goals

The Waxmans sought goals for their dog food with simple, yet important things.

• They wanted their dog food to be high-quality and human-grade, adhering to FDA and USDA standards.
• They wanted to avoid stress serving where you have to store food in the fridge, which takes up valuable space.
• Air-dried food locks up nutrients and proteins, which is important for dogs and better than most dog foods out there.
• All meals are natural and they have no preservatives and come in three different protein options: beef, chicken and turkey.
• Sundays Food for Dogs can cost around $4 a day

Sundays for Dogs Pros and Cons

Pros

• High-Quality Ingredients: Every meal produced by Sundays for Dogs is made with all-natural, human-grade ingredients. This means your dog gets top-notch nutrition without unnecessary fillers or artificial additives.
• Air-Dried Process: They also air-dry their food. The air-drying method preserves the nutrients and natural flavors of the ingredients. This means your dog is getting a healthier alternative to traditional kibble.
• Convenience: Every meal combines the convenience of dry food with the nutritional benefits of fresh food, making it easy to store and serve. They also deliver right to your doorstep on a regular basis, so you don’t have to worry if you run out of food.
• Transparency: Sundays for Dogs is transparent about their ingredient sourcing and their manufacturing process, which builds trust with pet owners.
• Veterinarian-Developed Recipes: All recipes are created and approved by veterinarians and pet nutritionists, which is why all of their meals meet the nutritional needs of dogs.
• Highly Palatable: The air-dried process enhances the flavor, making it highly palatable and enjoyable for dogs. Even the picky eaters, according to Sundays for Dogs, love their food.

Cons

• Price: Sundays for Dogs can be more expensive than traditional kibble bought in stores or other subscription services.
• Availability: The dog food may not be readily available when you order, so keep in mind it can take a few weeks to start the subscription and delivery.
• Texture: Sundays for Dogs prides itself on air-dried food, but the texture may be off putting for some dogs and it can take a while to get used to. Likewise, making the transition from regular kibble to Sundays for Dogs can take a while and your dog may experience digestive issues during the transition period.
• Limited Variety: Because all meals are personalized with a range of formulas and flavors, sometimes there may be a limit to the availability than others. Be aware of that before purchasing your orders.

Why We Love Sundays for Dogs

There are a lot of reasons why we love Sunday Food for Dogs. They provide high quality, air-dried dog food that is human-grade, too. They strive for food that even picky eaters will like, too — combining the convenience of kibble with the nutritional benefits of fresh food. It contains no additives or fillers, including preservatives.

We also love the fact that all meals contain 80% meat, providing your pup with the protein necessary to be strong and healthy. Not only that, but all their meals are delicious, palatable, and even nutritious. And Sundays for Dogs also believes in transparency — listing their ingredient sourcing and using veterinarian nutritionists to create well-balanced meals.

Sundays for Dogs is dedicated to quality and convenience, which is why it’s popular among pups, pup owners, and us!

Bottom Line

And there you have it, that is how you compare Sundays for Dogs with The Farmer’s Dog. Both are subscription services that offer delivery to its customers. Both dog food companies also offer fresh, nutritious food that will ensure your dog gets the proper nutrients they deserve.

At the end of the day, the most important thing is for your dog to get a nutritious and completely balanced meal. The priority for your dog is to lead a happy and healthy life. Both dog food delivery services offer top-notch food that will do just that!

When your dog is being transported, healthy food and plenty of water is extremely important. The dog-loving transporters on CitizenShipper have experience with feeding and storing fresh food while on the road. If you need to transport a dog, look no further than our #1-rated dog transportation marketplace.

As a Proud Partner, we’re offering you a Special 80% Discount on your first box of The Farmer’s Dog!

Disclaimer: CitizenShipper is a partner of The Farmer’s Dog and may earn commissions by referring customers.