Gordon Setter vs Irish Setter: Key Differences & Traits

Gordon Setters and Irish Setters are both part of the setter family of dog breeds. These breeds belong to the Sporting Group recognized by the American Kennel Club. There are many similarities and differences, so let’s explore them below!

If you’re still on the market to buy a Gordon or Irish Setter, PuppySpot currently offers a $300 discount using the code PUPPY300, just click the banner below!

Physical Characteristics

Gordon Setters and Irish Setters have distinct physical traits that set them apart. Their appearances, sizes, and coat colors differ in notable ways.

Appearance

• Gordon Setters have a sturdy, muscular build. They look strong and capable of handling rugged terrain. Their heads are deep and broad with a well-defined stop.
• Irish Setters have a more elegant, athletic appearance. They have long, lean heads with a gentle expression. Their bodies are sleek and built for speed.
• Both breeds have long, silky ears and feathering on their legs and tails. Gordon Setters tend to look more substantial, while Irish Setters appear more graceful.

Size and Weight

Gordon Setters are typically larger and heavier than Irish Setters.

Gordon Setter:

• Height: 23-27 inches
• Weight: 45-80 pounds

Irish Setter:

• Height: 25-27 inches
• Weight: 60-70 pounds

Gordon Setters have a wider weight range and can be quite heavy for their height. Irish Setters are generally lighter and more uniformly sized.

Coat and Colors

• Gordon Setters have a distinctive black and tan coat. The base color is rich, glossy black with tan markings on the muzzle, throat, chest, and legs. Their coat is long, silky, and straight or slightly wavy.
• Irish Setters are known for their striking red coat. The color can range from deep mahogany to bright chestnut. Their coat is fine, silky, and of medium length.
• Both breeds require regular grooming to maintain their coats. They shed moderately year-round, with heavier shedding during seasonal changes.

Temperament and Personality

Gordon Setters and Irish Setters have distinct temperaments and personalities. Both breeds are known for their intelligence and friendly nature, but they differ in energy levels and social needs.

Behavioral Traits

• Gordon Setters are calm and composed. They have a steady temperament and are less prone to excitability. These dogs are intelligent and respond well to training. They can be reserved with strangers but are not typically aggressive.
• Irish Setters are playful and mischievous. They have high energy levels and need plenty of exercise. These dogs are quick learners but can be easily distracted. They tend to be more outgoing and friendly with strangers.
• Both breeds are sensitive to their owners’ moods and respond well to positive reinforcement.

Social Characteristics

• Gordon Setters are generally more independent. They can be aloof with strangers but are loyal to their families. These dogs may show some territorial behavior and can make good watchdogs.
• Irish Setters are very social and outgoing. They love being around people and other dogs. They are less likely to be territorial and may not be as effective as watchdogs.
• Both breeds benefit from early socialization to ensure they grow into well-rounded adults.

Affection and Interaction

• Gordon Setters are affectionate with their families but may not be as demonstrative. They show their love through loyalty and a desire to be near their owners. These dogs can be good with children but may be too reserved for very young kids.
• Irish Setters are very affectionate and loving. They are known for their sweet nature and enjoy cuddling. These dogs are great with children and make excellent family pets.
• Both breeds need plenty of interaction and exercise to stay happy and healthy.

Health and Care

Gordon Setters and Irish Setters are generally healthy breeds. They share some common health concerns but also have unique care needs. Proper maintenance, nutrition, and exercise are key to keeping these dogs happy and healthy.

Common Health Issues

• Both Gordon and Irish Setters can face certain health problems. Hip dysplasia is a concern for both breeds. This condition affects the hip joint and can cause pain and mobility issues.
• Bloat is another serious issue to watch for. It’s a life-threatening condition where the stomach fills with gas and twists.
• Progressive retinal atrophy, which can lead to blindness, affects both breeds. Regular eye check-ups are important.
• Gordon Setters may be prone to hypothyroidism. This condition affects the thyroid gland and can cause weight gain and skin problems.
• Irish Setters can be affected by canine leukocyte adhesion deficiency. This rare genetic disorder impacts the immune system.

Maintenance and Grooming

• Both breeds have long, silky coats that need regular care. Brushing 2-3 times a week helps prevent matting and reduces shedding.
• Gordon Setters have a black and tan coat. Irish Setters sport a striking red coat. Both need occasional baths to keep clean.
• Nail trimming and ear cleaning should be part of the routine care for both breeds. This helps prevent infections and discomfort.
• Neither breed is known for excessive drooling. This makes them relatively easy to keep clean compared to some other large breeds.
• Regular teeth brushing is important for both Setters to maintain good dental health and prevent gum disease.

Exercise and Nutrition

• Gordon and Irish Setters are active dogs with high energy levels. They need plenty of exercise to stay healthy and happy.
• Daily walks, runs, or playtime in a fenced yard are essential. Both breeds excel in hunting activities, which can provide great exercise.
• Mental stimulation is just as important as physical exercise. Training sessions and puzzle toys can help keep their minds sharp.
• A balanced diet is crucial for these active dogs. High-quality dog food that meets their energy needs is recommended.
• Portion control is important to prevent obesity, which can lead to other health issues. Always provide fresh water, especially after exercise.
• 

Training and Intelligence

Gordon Setters and Irish Setters are both smart dogs. They can learn new things quickly. Both breeds need firm, consistent training from an early age.

• Gordon Setters are known for their intelligence. They pick up commands well and enjoy learning. These dogs can be a bit stubborn at times. Owners should be patient and use positive methods.
• Irish Setters are also clever. They have a playful nature that can make training fun. These dogs may get distracted easily. Short, engaging sessions work best for them.
• Gordon Setters excel in obedience training. They can learn complex tasks and often do well in dog sports. Irish Setters also shine in training but may need more repetition.
• Both breeds benefit from early socialization. This helps them become well-behaved adults. Consistent rules and plenty of praise go a long way with these smart setters.

Breed-Specific Considerations

Gordon Setters and Irish Setters have unique traits that affect their suitability for different homes and families. These dogs have specific needs and tendencies that potential owners should understand.

Living Environment

• Gordon Setters and Irish Setters are large, active breeds that need space to move. They do best in homes with yards. Both breeds have moderate climate tolerance but prefer cooler weather.
• Gordon Setters adapt better to apartments if given enough exercise. Irish Setters need more space and are less suited to apartment living. Both have strong roaming instincts and high prey drives.
• Fenced yards are important for these breeds. They may chase small animals if not trained. Daily walks and playtime are essential for their physical and mental health.

Compatibility with Families

• Both Gordon and Irish Setters are affectionate family dogs. They love being part of family activities. These breeds are good with children when properly socialized.
• Gordon Setters tend to be more reserved with strangers. Irish Setters are usually friendlier to new people. Both can be great playmates for older kids who understand how to interact with dogs.
• These setters may experience separation anxiety if left alone too long. They thrive on human companionship and do best in homes where someone is often present.

Potential Challenges

• Training can be challenging for both breeds. They are intelligent but can be stubborn. Consistent, positive training methods work best. Early socialization is key to prevent shyness or aggression.
• Barking can be an issue, especially for Irish Setters. Gordon Setters are generally quieter. Both breeds have a strong prey drive and may chase small animals.
• These dogs need lots of exercise. Without enough activity, they may become destructive or develop behavior problems. Regular grooming is necessary to maintain their coats and prevent matting.