English Setter vs Gordon Setter: Key Differences Explained

English Setters and Gordon Setters are both beloved sporting dogs with rich histories. You’ll find they share some similarities but also have key differences in their origins, classifications, and recognition by kennel clubs. Let’s take a look at the similarities and differences between these two dog breeds.

If you’re still on the market to buy an Irish Setter or Gordon Setter, PuppySpot currently offers a $300 discount using the code PUPPY300, just click the banner below!

Physical Characteristics

English Setters and Gordon Setters have distinct looks. Their sizes, coats, and unique features set them apart. Let’s explore these differences.

Size Comparison

• English Setters are medium-sized dogs. They stand 24-27 inches tall for males and 23-26 inches for females. Their weight ranges from 65-80 pounds for males and 55-70 pounds for females.
• Gordon Setters are larger and sturdier. Males measure 24-27 inches and females 23-26 inches. They weigh more, with males at 55-80 pounds and females at 45-70 pounds.
• You’ll notice Gordon Setters have a heavier build. Their bodies are more square-shaped compared to the slightly rectangular shape of English Setters.

Coat and Color Variations

English Setters have a distinctive coat. It’s long, silky, and flat with feathering on the ears, chest, belly, and legs. Their base color is white with speckles of another color, called “belton.”

Common belton colors include:

• Blue (black and white)
• Orange
• Lemon
• Liver (brown)
• Tricolor (black, tan, and white)

Gordon Setters have a different look. Their coat is black and tan. The black is deep and glossy, with rich chestnut or mahogany markings. These tan spots appear on their muzzle, throat, chest, legs, and under the tail. Their coat is shorter on the head and front of the legs. It’s longer on the ears, chest, belly, back of legs, and tail.

Distinctive Features

• English Setters have a lean, elegant appearance. Their head is long and oval-shaped with a square muzzle. Their ears are set low and hang in graceful folds.
• You’ll notice their eyes are dark brown and have a soft, intelligent expression. Their tail is long and tapered, carried level with their back.
• Gordon Setters have a more robust look. Their head is deep and somewhat rounded with a long muzzle. Their eyes are dark brown or black and set deep.
• Their ears are large and thin, hanging close to their head. Gordon Setters have a long tail that’s thick at the base and tapers to a point. They carry it straight or with a slight curve.
• Both breeds have a noble, alert expression. But the Gordon’s darker coloring gives them a more intense look compared to the softer appearance of the English Setter.

Temperament and Personality

English Setters and Gordon Setters have distinct personalities that set them apart. Both breeds are known for their friendly nature, but they differ in energy levels and social needs.

Behavioral Traits

• English Setters are gentle and mild-mannered. They have a calm demeanor and adapt well to different environments. These dogs are patient with children and other pets.
• Gordon Setters are more intense and strong-willed. They have a higher energy level and need more exercise. These dogs can be protective of their family and may be wary of strangers.
• Both breeds are intelligent and trainable. English Setters learn quickly but can be stubborn at times. Gordon Setters are eager to please but may need firm, consistent training.

Affection and Loyalty

• English Setters are very affectionate dogs. They bond closely with their families and enjoy cuddles and attention. These dogs are known for their sweet, loving nature.
• Gordon Setters are equally loyal but may be more reserved. They form strong bonds with their owners and are devoted family pets. These dogs can be protective of their loved ones.
• Both breeds make excellent companions. English Setters are more likely to seek constant attention, while Gordon Setters are content with regular interaction and affection.

Social Interaction

• English Setters are friendly and outgoing. They enjoy meeting new people and get along well with other dogs. These social butterflies thrive on companionship and don’t like being left alone for long periods.
• Gordon Setters are more reserved with strangers. They may take time to warm up to new people but are generally friendly once they do. These dogs can be independent and may not seek constant attention like English Setters.
• Both breeds benefit from early socialization. This helps them develop into well-rounded, confident dogs. Regular interaction with people and other pets is important for their social development.

Health and Lifespan

English Setters and Gordon Setters have some differences in their health and lifespan. You’ll want to know about these factors when choosing between the two breeds. English Setters typically live 10-12 years, while Gordon Setters have a slightly longer average lifespan of 12-14 years.

Both breeds can face some health issues:

• English Setters: prone to hip dysplasia, deafness, and certain eye problems
• Gordon Setters: may experience hip dysplasia, eye issues, and bloat

Regular vet check-ups are important for both breeds to catch and treat any health problems early.

To keep your setter healthy, make sure to:

• Provide a balanced diet
• Give plenty of exercise
• Keep up with vaccinations
• Brush their coat regularly

By taking good care of your setter, you can help them live a long, happy life. Remember that each dog is unique, and your pet’s health may vary from these general guidelines.

Exercise and Activity Requirements

English Setters and Gordon Setters are energetic dogs with high exercise needs. Both breeds require regular physical activity to stay healthy and happy.

Exercise Needs

English Setters need high to very high levels of exercise. They thrive on daily walks, runs, or hikes. Aim for at least 1-2 hours of activity each day. Gordon Setters also have high exercise requirements. They enjoy long walks, jogging, and playing fetch. Plan for 60-90 minutes of daily exercise.

Both breeds benefit from:

• Off-leash running in secure areas
• Swimming
• Agility training
• Hunting activities (if trained)

Remember to adjust exercise intensity based on your dog’s age and health.

Suitability for Active Families

English Setters and Gordon Setters are great matches for active families. Their energy levels make them ideal companions for outdoor adventures.

English Setters adapt well to various activities. You’ll find them eager participants in:

• Family hikes
• Beach outings
• Camping trips

Gordon Setters excel in structured activities. They enjoy:

• Obedience training
• Tracking exercises
• Hunting-related sports

Both breeds need mental stimulation along with physical exercise. Puzzle toys and training sessions help keep their minds sharp. Choose the breed that best fits your lifestyle and activity preferences. Either setter will thrive with an active family committed to meeting their exercise needs.

Training and Intelligence

English Setters and Gordon Setters are smart dogs with strong hunting skills. They need proper training to reach their full potential as working or family dogs.

Trainability and Intelligence Factors

• Both breeds are intelligent and trainable. English Setters tend to be more easy-going and eager to please. This can make them quicker to pick up commands. Gordon Setters are smart but can be stubborn at times. They may need more patience and consistent training.
• You’ll find English Setters respond well to positive reinforcement. Treats and praise work wonders. Gordon Setters benefit from firm but gentle guidance. They do best with an experienced owner who can provide clear leadership.
• Both dogs excel at obedience training when started young. Early socialization is key for either breed to develop good manners around people and other pets.

Hunting and Working Capabilities

• As hunting dogs, both setters have strong instincts and skills. English Setters are known for their “bird sense” and ability to work in open fields. They have a keen nose and can cover ground quickly.
• Gordon Setters are powerful hunters built for stamina. They excel in rough terrain and cold weather. These dogs have a strong pointing instinct and are skilled at tracking game birds.
• You’ll find both breeds make great working dogs beyond hunting. Their intelligence suits them for roles like therapy work or search and rescue. With proper training, they can excel in dog sports like agility or rally.
• English Setters may adapt more easily to non-hunting homes. Gordon Setters often need more mental and physical stimulation to stay happy.

Grooming and Care

English Setters and Gordon Setters have different grooming and dietary needs. Knowing these differences can help you choose the right breed for your lifestyle.

Grooming Needs

Both English and Gordon Setters require regular grooming, but there are some key differences. English Setters have medium grooming needs, while Gordon Setters need medium to high maintenance.

For English Setters:

• Brush their coat 2-3 times a week
• Bathe every 4-6 weeks
• Trim nails monthly
• Clean ears weekly

Gordon Setters need more attention:

• Brush their coat daily
• Bathe every 4-6 weeks
• Trim nails every 2-3 weeks
• Clean ears weekly

Both breeds shed moderately. You’ll need to pay extra attention during shedding seasons. Regular grooming helps reduce loose hair and keeps their coats healthy.

Dietary Requirements

Both English and Gordon Setters need high-quality dog food to stay healthy. Your dog’s diet should match their age, size, and activity level.

For English Setters:

• Feed 2-3 cups of dry food daily, split into two meals
• Choose food high in protein and moderate in fat
• Avoid overfeeding to prevent obesity

Gordon Setters have similar needs:

• Feed 3-4 cups of dry food daily, split into two meals
• Select food rich in protein for muscle maintenance
• Monitor calorie intake to keep them at a healthy weight

Always provide fresh water for both breeds. Consult your vet for personalized dietary advice based on your dog’s specific needs.

Living Conditions

English Setters and Gordon Setters have different needs when it comes to their living environment. Their adaptability and compatibility with other pets can vary.

Indoor/Outdoor Adaptability

• English Setters adapt well to apartment living if given enough exercise. They’re calm indoors but need daily walks and playtime. These dogs have a moderate roaming instinct, so a fenced yard is best.
• Gordon Setters need more space. They’re less suited for apartments due to their size and energy levels. Your Gordon Setter will thrive with a large, fenced yard to explore and run in.
• Both breeds enjoy outdoor activities. English Setters are more adaptable to different lifestyles. Gordon Setters prefer homes with active owners who can provide plenty of exercise.

Compatibility with Other Pets

• English Setters are generally friendly with other dogs and pets. They have a gentle nature and can get along well in multi-pet households. Early socialization helps ensure good behavior.
• Gordon Setters can be more territorial and may not always get along with other dogs, especially of the same sex. They have a strong prey drive, which might make them chase smaller pets.
• Both breeds benefit from proper introductions to new pets. Supervise interactions until you’re sure they’re comfortable with each other.