Scottish vs Cairn Terrier: Feisty Terrier Temperament Face-Off

The Scottish Terrier and Cairn Terrier both come from Scotland. They share roots as working dogs bred to hunt small prey. But each breed has its own unique history and development. Let’s take a look at the similarities and differences between these two dog breeds.

If you’re still on the market to buy a Scottish Terrier or Cairn Terrier, PuppySpot currently offers a $300 discount using the code PUPPY300, just click the banner below!

Physical Characteristics

Scottish Terriers and Cairn Terriers have distinct physical features that set them apart. These small dogs share some similarities but differ in key aspects of their appearance.

Comparing Body Structures

• Scottish Terriers, or Scotties, have a compact and sturdy build. They stand about 10 inches tall at the shoulder. Their bodies are longer than they are tall, giving them a rectangular shape. Scotties have a distinctive beard and eyebrows, with small, pointed ears.
• Cairn Terriers are slightly smaller, standing 9-10 inches tall. They have a more proportionate body shape, appearing almost square when viewed from the side. Cairns have a round head with a short muzzle and erect ears.
• Both breeds have strong legs and deep chests, but Scotties tend to be heavier, weighing 18-22 pounds. Cairns are lighter, typically 13-14 pounds.

Coat and Coloring Differences

• Both breeds have a double coat, but their textures differ. Scottish Terriers have a hard, wiry outer coat with a soft, dense undercoat. Their coat is typically black, but can also be brindle or wheaten.
• Cairn Terriers have a shaggy, weather-resistant outer coat with a soft undercoat. Their coat comes in various colors, including red, brindle, black, and cream. Cairns often change color as they age.
• Grooming needs vary. Scotties require regular brushing and trimming. Cairns need less frequent grooming but should be hand-stripped to maintain their coat texture.
• Both breeds shed minimally, making them good choices for allergy sufferers. Unlike their cousin, the West Highland White Terrier (Westie), neither Scotties nor Cairns come in pure white.

Temperament and Personality

Scottish Terriers and Cairn Terriers have distinct personalities. Both breeds are known for their feisty and spirited natures, but they differ in some key behavioral traits.

Behavioral Traits of Scottish Terriers

Scottish Terriers are independent and dignified dogs. As Tracey Squaire in “Complete Guide to Scottish Terriers” stated, “Scottish Terriers carry themselves with dignity akin to their historical role as solitary hunters; their independence requires patient socialisation.” They can be aloof with strangers but are loyal to their families. These terriers have a strong-willed nature that can make training challenging.

Scotties are known for their:

• Courage and confidence
• Protective instincts
• Stubbornness

You’ll find Scottish Terriers to be intelligent and alert. They make excellent watchdogs due to their protective nature. Scotties can be stubborn, which may require patience during training sessions. As hunting dogs, they have a high prey drive. This means they might chase small animals. Scotties can be good family pets but may not be ideal for homes with very young children.

Cairn Terrier Dispositions

Cairn Terriers are known for their friendly and outgoing personalities. They are generally more adaptable than Scottish Terriers and often get along well with other pets.

Key traits of Cairn Terriers include:

• Playfulness
• Curiosity
• Affectionate nature

You’ll find Cairn Terriers to be energetic and cheerful companions. They love to play and are always ready for adventure. These terriers are typically good with children and make excellent family pets. Cairns are intelligent and respond well to positive reinforcement training. They can be stubborn at times but are generally eager to please. Their friendly nature makes them more sociable than Scottish Terriers.

As terriers, Cairns still have a strong prey drive. They may chase small animals if not properly trained. Regular exercise and mental stimulation are important to keep these lively dogs happy.

Grooming and Care

Both Scottish and Cairn Terriers need regular grooming to keep their coats healthy. Their double coats require different approaches to maintenance.

Scottish Terrier Grooming Needs

• Scottish Terriers have a harsh outer coat and soft undercoat. You’ll need to brush your Scottie 2-3 times a week to prevent mats. Use a slicker brush and metal comb to remove loose hair and tangles.
• Hand-stripping is important for Scotties every 3-4 months. This keeps their coat texture correct and helps shed the undercoat. If you don’t want to hand-strip, clipping is an option, but it can soften the coat over time.
• Bathe your Scottish Terrier only when necessary to avoid drying out their skin. Trim their nails regularly and clean their ears weekly to prevent infections.

Cairn Terrier Maintenance

• Cairn Terriers have a shaggy double coat that sheds minimally. You’ll need to brush your Cairn 1-2 times a week to remove dead hair and prevent mats. Use a slicker brush and metal comb for best results.
• Like Scotties, Cairns benefit from hand-stripping every few months. This keeps their coat looking tidy and helps maintain its weather-resistant properties. If you prefer, you can have your Cairn clipped instead.
• Bathe your Cairn Terrier only when they get dirty. Over-bathing can strip their coat of natural oils. Trim their nails regularly and check their ears weekly for signs of infection or wax buildup.

Health and Lifespan

Scottish Terriers and Cairn Terriers face different health challenges. Their lifespans vary, with Cairn Terriers generally living longer. Both breeds need regular vet check-ups to stay healthy.

Common Health Issues in Scottish Terriers

Scottish Terriers are prone to several health problems. You should watch for:

• Von Willebrand’s Disease: A blood clotting disorder
• Craniomandibular Osteopathy: Jaw bone growth issues
• Scottie Cramp: A movement disorder

They may also face skin allergies and thyroid problems. Scottish Terriers have a higher risk of bladder cancer than other breeds. Their average lifespan is 11-13 years. Regular exercise and a healthy diet can help your Scottie live longer. Dental care is important too, as they can develop teeth problems.

Cairn Terriers: Health Considerations

Cairn Terriers are generally healthier, with a lifespan of 13-15 years. But they still have some health issues to watch for:

• Glaucoma: Increased eye pressure
• Cryptorchidism: Undescended testicles in males
• Patellar Luxation: Kneecap dislocation

Cairns can also develop skin allergies and eye problems. They may be prone to weight gain, so watch their diet. Regular vet check-ups are key for early detection of health issues. Dental care is important for Cairns too. Keep their teeth clean to prevent gum disease.

Training and Obedience

Scottish Terriers and Cairn Terriers have different training needs. Both breeds can be stubborn, but with the right approach, you can achieve success in obedience and agility training.

Training Approaches for Scottish Terriers

Scottish Terriers are independent and robust. To train them effectively:

• Start early and be consistent
• Use positive reinforcement techniques
• Keep training sessions short and fun
• Be patient and persistent

Scottish Terriers respond well to praise and treats. Avoid harsh corrections, as they can make your Scottie more stubborn. Focus on basic obedience commands like sit, stay, and come. For agility training, introduce obstacles gradually. Scottish Terriers excel in tasks that challenge their problem-solving skills. Remember to always end training sessions on a positive note.

Effective Training for Cairn Terriers

Cairn Terriers are playful and respond well to training. “Positive reinforcement aligns best with cairns’ intelligence—short sessions prevent boredom-driven stubbornness,” stated Drs. Yvonne van Zeeland et al. in Applied Animal Behaviour Science, Vol 45(3).

To train your Cairn effectively:

• Use short, engaging training sessions
• Incorporate play into your training routine
• Be firm but gentle in your approach
• Provide mental stimulation

Cairn Terriers thrive on variety. Mix up your training exercises to keep them interested. Use toys as rewards alongside treats. Mental stimulation is crucial for this breed. For obedience training, focus on recall and leash manners. Cairns can be easily distracted, so work on attention exercises. In agility, their small size and agility make them natural competitors.

Activities and Exercise

Scottish Terriers and Cairn Terriers are active breeds that need regular exercise. Both dogs enjoy playtime and physical activities to stay healthy and happy.

Exercise Needs of Scottish Terriers

Scottish Terriers need about 30-60 minutes of exercise daily. You can split this into two walks or play sessions. These dogs have moderate energy levels and don’t require intense workouts. Scotties enjoy short walks and indoor games. They’re not built for long-distance running, but they like to explore.

Try these activities with your Scottish Terrier:

• Short walks around the neighborhood
• Backyard play sessions
• Indoor fetch or tug-of-war
• Nose work games

Remember, Scotties can be stubborn. Use positive reinforcement to keep exercise fun and engaging.

Play and Activity for Cairn Terriers

Cairn Terriers are lively dogs that need 30-60 minutes of daily exercise. They have more energy than Scottish Terriers and enjoy a variety of activities. Cairn Terriers love to work and play. They excel in dog sports like agility and earthdog trials. These activities tap into their hunting instincts.

Fun activities for your Cairn Terrier include:

• Brisk walks or jogs
• Fetch and frisbee in the yard
• Agility courses (homemade or professional)
• Hide-and-seek with toys or treats

Cairns are smart and need mental stimulation. Mix up their routine to keep them engaged and prevent boredom.