Old English Sheepdog vs Bearded Collie: Top Herding Breeds Compared

The Old English Sheepdog and Bearded Collie have distinct origins in the United Kingdom. Both breeds were developed for herding, but they emerged from different regions and time periods. Let’s explore the similarities and differences between these two breeds.

If you’re still on the market to buy an Old English Sheepdog or Bearded Collie, PuppySpot currently offers a $300 discount using the code PUPPY300, just click the banner below!

Physical Characteristics and Appearance

Old English Sheepdogs and Bearded Collies have distinct looks. Their sizes, coats, and colors set them apart. Let’s look at each breed’s unique features.

Old English Sheepdog Appearance

• Old English Sheepdogs are big, sturdy dogs. They stand 22 to 24 inches tall at the shoulder. Males weigh 60 to 100 pounds, while females are slightly smaller.
• Their most striking feature is their thick, shaggy double coat. It covers their whole body, including their face. The coat can be gray, blue, or blue merle, often with white markings.
• Old English Sheepdogs have a characteristic bobtail. This short tail is either natural or docked. Their eyes are often hidden under their fluffy fur, giving them a lovable, shaggy-dog look.

Bearded Collie Appearance

• Bearded Collies are medium-sized dogs. They stand 20 to 22 inches tall. Their weight ranges from 40 to 60 pounds.
• These dogs have a long, shaggy double coat. Their fur is softer and more flowing than the Old English Sheepdog’s. It comes in black, blue, brown, or fawn, often with white markings.
• Bearded Collies have a distinctive beard-like growth under their chin. Their coat forms “eyebrows” that fall over their eyes. Unlike Old English Sheepdogs, they have long tails that are usually not docked.

Behavioral Traits and Temperament

Old English Sheepdogs and Bearded Collies have distinct personalities. Both breeds are intelligent and friendly, but they differ in energy levels and social needs.

Old English Sheepdog Temperament

• Old English Sheepdogs are known for their affectionate and loving nature. They are gentle giants with a calm demeanor. These dogs are patient and good with children, making them excellent family pets.
• Old English Sheepdogs can be stubborn at times. They need consistent training from an early age. Despite their large size, they are playful and enjoy being around their families.
• These dogs are intelligent but may have an independent streak. They respond well to positive reinforcement. Old English Sheepdogs can be protective of their homes and families.

Bearded Collie Temperament

• Bearded Collies are energetic and outgoing dogs. They have a lively personality and love to be active. These dogs are known for their cheerful disposition and bouncy nature.
• Bearded Collies are highly intelligent and eager to please. They excel in obedience training and various dog sports. Their herding instincts are strong, which can lead to them trying to herd children or other pets.
• These dogs are very sociable and thrive on human companionship. They can become anxious if left alone for long periods. Bearded Collies are generally good with other dogs and pets when properly socialized.

Health and Lifespan

Old English Sheepdogs and Bearded Collies have different health profiles and lifespans. Both breeds face some common health issues, but they also have unique concerns to watch out for.

Old English Sheepdog Health

• Old English Sheepdogs typically live 10-11 years. They are prone to certain health problems. Hip dysplasia is a common issue in this breed, causing pain and mobility problems.
• Eye problems can also affect Old English Sheepdogs. These may include cataracts and progressive retinal atrophy. Regular eye check-ups are important.
• This breed can be at risk for bloat, a serious stomach condition. Owners should be aware of the signs and seek immediate vet care if suspected.
• Hypothyroidism is another concern for Old English Sheepdogs. This condition affects the thyroid gland and can lead to weight gain and skin issues.

Bearded Collie Health

• Bearded Collies generally enjoy a longer lifespan of 12-14 years. They have their own set of health concerns to monitor.
• Hip dysplasia can also affect Bearded Collies, though it’s less common than in Old English Sheepdogs. Regular exercise and maintaining a healthy weight can help.
• Autoimmune diseases are a concern in this breed. These can affect various body systems and require ongoing management.
• Bearded Collies may develop hypothyroidism, similar to Old English Sheepdogs. Symptoms include weight gain, lethargy, and coat problems.
• Eye issues like cataracts can occur in Bearded Collies. Regular vet check-ups can help catch and treat these problems early.

Grooming and Maintenance

Both Old English Sheepdogs and Bearded Collies have long, shaggy coats that need regular care. Their grooming needs are similar, but there are some key differences.

Old English Sheepdog Grooming

• Old English Sheepdogs have a thick, double coat that requires frequent brushing. They should be brushed at least 3-4 times a week to prevent matting and tangling.
• Their coat sheds heavily, especially during seasonal changes. Regular bathing every 6-8 weeks helps keep their coat clean and healthy.
• Trimming is necessary every 6-8 weeks to maintain a neat appearance. Particular attention should be paid to the hair around their eyes and feet.
• Old English Sheepdogs also need regular nail trims, ear cleaning, and teeth brushing.

Bearded Collie Grooming

• Bearded Collies have a long, shaggy double coat that requires consistent care. They need brushing 2-3 times a week to prevent matting and remove loose hair.
• Their shedding is moderate compared to Old English Sheepdogs. Bathing should be done every 8-12 weeks or when necessary.
• Trimming is not as extensive as for Old English Sheepdogs, but regular trimming around the feet and face is important. Their signature “beard” needs special attention to keep it clean and tangle-free.
• Like Old English Sheepdogs, Bearded Collies also require regular nail trims, ear cleaning, and dental care.

Training and Intelligence

Both Old English Sheepdogs and Bearded Collies are smart breeds that need proper training. They have different learning styles and abilities that affect how easy they are to train.

Training Needs

• Old English Sheepdogs can be stubborn during training. They need a firm, consistent approach. Short, fun sessions work best to keep their interest.
• Bearded Collies are eager to please. They pick up commands quickly. Positive reinforcement helps them learn fast.
• Both breeds do well with early socialization. This helps prevent shyness or fear as they grow up.
• For herding tasks, Old English Sheepdogs may need more patience. Bearded Collies often grasp herding concepts faster.

Intelligence Comparison

• Both breeds score above average in intelligence. Bearded Collies tend to be quicker learners. They excel in obedience and agility competitions.
• Old English Sheepdogs are also smart. But they can be independent thinkers. This may make them seem less intelligent at times.
• Bearded Collies often respond better to complex commands. Old English Sheepdogs might need more repetition to master tricky tasks.
• In problem-solving, Bearded Collies usually show more initiative. Old English Sheepdogs can solve problems too, but may need more guidance.

Exercise and Activity Needs

Old English Sheepdogs and Bearded Collies are active breeds that need plenty of exercise. Both dogs thrive on regular physical activity to stay healthy and happy.

Recommended Exercise Routines

Old English Sheepdogs have high exercise needs. They require daily walks, playtime, and mental stimulation. A good routine includes:

• 1-2 long walks (30-60 minutes each)
  • Off-leash running in a fenced area
  • Fetch or frisbee games
  • Agility training or herding activities

Bearded Collies have even higher energy levels. Their exercise routine should be more intense:

• 2-3 vigorous walks or jogs (45-60 minutes each)
  • Plenty of off-leash running time
  • Interactive games like hide-and-seek
  • Agility courses or herding trials

Both breeds enjoy swimming as a low-impact exercise option. Without enough activity, these dogs may become bored and destructive. Regular exercise helps maintain their physical and mental well-being.

Compatibility as Family Pets

Both Old English Sheepdogs and Bearded Collies can make great family pets. They are playful, energetic, and sociable breeds that enjoy being part of a family unit.

Old English Sheepdog as a Family Pet

• Old English Sheepdogs are ideal family pets. They form strong bonds with their human families and are known for their affectionate nature. These dogs are patient and tolerant, making them great companions for children.
• Old English Sheepdogs are playful and energetic. They need regular exercise to stay happy and healthy. Daily walks and playtime in a fenced yard are essential.
• These dogs can be good watchdogs. They may bark to alert their family of strangers. However, they are usually friendly once they know someone is welcome.
• Old English Sheepdogs can suffer from separation anxiety if left alone for long periods. They thrive on human companionship and do best in homes where someone is often around.

Bearded Collie as a Family Pet

• Bearded Collies are friendly and outgoing. They make excellent family pets, especially for active households. These dogs are known for their playful and energetic nature.
• Bearded Collies are good with children and other pets when properly socialized. They have a strong herding instinct, which may lead to them trying to herd small children or animals.
• These dogs need plenty of exercise and mental stimulation. Daily walks, runs, or play sessions are important to keep them happy and well-behaved.
• Bearded Collies can be vocal. They may bark to alert their family of visitors or changes in their environment. Early training can help manage excessive barking.
• Like Old English Sheepdogs, these dogs can develop separation anxiety. They enjoy being part of family activities and may become stressed if left alone too often.