Irish Setter vs Gordon Setter: Which Breed Fits Your Lifestyle?

Cagri Sarigoz Cagri Sarigoz · Updated January 24, 2025

Ensure Your Furry Friend's Comfort!

  • Fast and easy
  • Only pay when you book
Two dogs sit on the grass in a park, showcasing a delightful breed comparison. One is black and white like a Gordon Setter, and the other is rich brown, reminiscent of an Irish Setter. Trees and sunlight blur beautifully in the background.

Irish Setters and Gordon Setters are both popular sporting dogs. They share some traits but differ in key ways. Let’s look at their origins and physical features.

If you’re still on the market to buy an Irish Setter or Gordon Setter, PuppySpot currently offers a $300 discount using the code PUPPY300, just click the banner below!

Golden retriever puppy on a sunny path with "PuppySpot" logo and text: "The best place to discover your puppy." Button reads "Find a Puppy.

Appearance and Coat Type

  • Irish Setters are known for their red coats. They have long, silky fur that can be straight or wavy. These dogs are tall and lean with long legs.
  • Gordon Setters look different. They have black coats with tan markings. Their fur is thick and either wavy or straight. Gordon Setters are more muscular than Irish Setters.
  • Both breeds have long, floppy ears and feathering on their legs and tails. Irish Setters tend to be slightly taller. Gordon Setters are usually heavier and more compact.

Two dogs frolic gleefully on a grassy field; one, a graceful Gordon Setter, and the other is black and white. Trees and hills paint the background, capturing their lively breed lifestyle.

Physical Traits

Irish Setters and Gordon Setters have distinct physical characteristics that set them apart. Their size, weight, and health issues differ in important ways.

Size and Weight Comparison

  • Irish Setters are slightly taller and leaner than Gordon Setters. Irish Setters stand between 25 to 27 inches tall. Gordon Setters are a bit shorter, measuring 23 to 27 inches in height.
  • Gordon Setters have a more muscular build. They typically weigh 25 to 30 kilograms. Irish Setters are lankier with longer bones.
  • The coat colors of these breeds differ significantly. Irish Setters sport a striking red coat. Gordon Setters have a black coat with tan markings.

Typical Health Issues

  • Both breeds can face certain health problems. Hip dysplasia is a concern for Irish and Gordon Setters. This condition affects the hip joint and can cause pain and mobility issues.
  • Progressive retinal atrophy, a degenerative eye disease, can occur in both breeds. Regular eye check-ups are important to catch this early.
  • Bloat is another health risk for these large-chested dogs. It’s a serious condition that requires immediate veterinary attention.
  • Gordon Setters may have a slightly shorter lifespan than Irish Setters. Regular vet check-ups are crucial for both breeds to maintain good health and catch any issues early.

Personality and Behavior

Irish Setters and Gordon Setters have distinct personalities that shape their behavior. Both breeds are known for their friendly nature, but they differ in energy levels and social needs.

Temperament Overview

  • Irish Setters are cheerful and outgoing dogs. They love being around people and have a playful, sometimes silly side. These dogs are always ready for fun and adventure.
  • Gordon Setters are more reserved and calm. They tend to be serious and focused, especially when working. Gordon Setters are loyal and devoted to their families.
  • Both breeds are gentle and patient with children. They make great family pets due to their friendly nature.

Energy Levels and Playfulness

  • Irish Setters have high energy levels. They need lots of exercise and playtime to stay happy and healthy. These dogs enjoy running, fetching, and other active games.
  • Gordon Setters are also energetic but not as hyperactive as Irish Setters. They like long walks and outdoor activities. Gordon Setters can be playful but in a more controlled manner.
  • Both breeds may have a strong impulse to wander or roam, especially if they catch an interesting scent. Secure fencing is important for their safety.

Social Needs and Family Compatibility

  • Irish Setters are very social dogs. They thrive on human companionship and don’t like being left alone for long periods. These dogs fit well in active families who can give them plenty of attention.
  • Gordon Setters are also affectionate and loving. They form strong bonds with their families but may be slightly more independent than Irish Setters.
  • Both breeds get along well with other pets when properly socialized. They have a natural prey drive, so early training is important to manage this instinct around smaller animals.

A joyful Gordon Setter and a playful black and white dog dash across the green grass, their sleek coats glistening in the sunlight as blurred trees sway behind them.

Care Requirements

Irish Setters and Gordon Setters have different care needs. Their grooming, exercise, and diet requirements vary due to their distinct physical traits and energy levels.

Grooming and Maintenance Needs

  • Gordon Setters have a thick, wavy coat that needs regular brushing. Brush them 2-3 times a week to prevent matting. Irish Setters have a silky, flat coat that’s easier to maintain. Brush them once or twice weekly.
  • Both breeds shed moderately. During shedding seasons, increase brushing frequency.
  • Trim nails monthly for both breeds. Clean ears weekly to prevent infections. Bathe every 6-8 weeks or when dirty.
  • Gordon Setters may need more frequent grooming due to their thicker coat. Professional grooming every 8-12 weeks can help maintain coat health.

Exercise Demands and Activity

  • Irish Setters are very energetic and need lots of exercise. They require 1-2 hours of activity daily. Long walks, runs, or playtime in a fenced yard are ideal.
  • Gordon Setters need moderate exercise. An hour of daily activity is usually enough. They enjoy walks, hikes, and swimming.
  • Both breeds benefit from mental stimulation. Puzzle toys and training sessions help keep their minds sharp.
  • Irish Setters may be better suited for active families. Gordon Setters adapt well to different lifestyles but still need regular exercise.

Diet and Feeding Tips

  • Feed both breeds high-quality dog food appropriate for their age and size. Divide daily portions into two meals.
  • Irish Setters have fast metabolisms. They may need more calories, especially if very active. Monitor their weight and adjust portions as needed.
  • Gordon Setters are prone to bloat. Feed them smaller, more frequent meals. Use elevated food bowls to reduce risk.
  • Both breeds benefit from food with omega-3 fatty acids for coat health. Add fish oil supplements if needed.
  • Watch for food allergies in both breeds. If skin issues occur, consult a vet about changing their diet.

Training and Intelligence

Irish Setters and Gordon Setters are both smart breeds. They have different strengths when it comes to training and working. Let’s look at how they compare in learning, obedience, and hunting skills.

Trainability and Learning Capacity

Irish Setters are quick learners but can be easily distracted. They need varied training sessions to stay focused. Gordon Setters learn well too, but they can be stubborn at times. Both breeds do best with positive rewards.

Irish Setters excel in:
• Agility training
• Trick learning
• Social skills

Gordon Setters are good at:
• Following complex commands
• Focused tasks
• Problem-solving

Both breeds need early training. This helps them develop good habits. Consistency is key for both Irish and Gordon Setters.

Obedience and Agility

Irish Setters are energetic and love to move. They do well in agility courses. Gordon Setters are more reserved but still athletic.

Irish Setters:
• Quick and nimble
• May get distracted during obedience
• Need lots of exercise

Gordon Setters:
• Steady and focused
• More reliable in obedience
• Require regular activity

Both breeds benefit from obedience classes. Irish Setters might need more patience in training. Gordon Setters often pick up commands faster.

Two spaniels stand on a grassy field; one with brown and white fur, the other with black, brown, and white fur. Both wear collars with tags. This scene invites a gentle breed comparison to noble companions like the Gordon Setter amidst lush greenery in the background.

Living With Setters

Irish and Gordon Setters are energetic dogs that need plenty of exercise and attention. Their adaptability and family-friendly nature make them great companions, but they have some key differences to consider.

Adaptability to Living Environments

  • Irish Setters are more adaptable to lifestyle changes than Gordon Setters. They can adjust to apartment living if given enough exercise. Gordon Setters prefer homes with yards. Both breeds need daily walks and playtime.
  • Irish Setters have higher energy levels. They require more physical activity and mental stimulation. Gordon Setters are calmer but still need regular exercise.
  • Neither breed does well when left alone for long periods. They thrive on human companionship and can become anxious or destructive if isolated.

Considerations for Potential Owners

  • Both Irish and Gordon Setters make excellent family dogs. They are gentle with children and get along well with other pets. Their friendly nature means they may not be ideal watchdogs.
  • These breeds shed moderately and need regular grooming. Brushing 2-3 times a week helps maintain their coats.
  • Training is essential for both breeds. They can be stubborn, so consistent, positive reinforcement works best. Early socialization is important to prevent shyness or aggression.
  • Potential health issues include hip dysplasia and eye problems. Regular vet check-ups are necessary to catch and treat any issues early.

Healthcare and Wellness

Irish Setters and Gordon Setters face some similar health issues, but differ in lifespan and aging processes. Both breeds need regular vet check-ups and proper care to stay healthy.

Common Health Issues and Prevention

  • Hip dysplasia affects both Irish and Gordon Setters. This joint problem can cause pain and mobility issues. Regular exercise and maintaining a healthy weight help prevent it.
  • Bloat is another concern for both breeds. It’s a serious condition where the stomach fills with gas. To reduce risk, feed smaller meals and avoid exercise right after eating.
  • Irish Setters can develop canine leukocyte adhesion deficiency, a rare immune system disorder. Genetic testing helps identify at-risk dogs.
  • Hypothyroidism is more common in Gordon Setters. This condition affects metabolism. Signs include weight gain and lethargy. Regular blood tests can catch it early.

Lifespan and Aging

  • Irish Setters typically live 12-15 years, while Gordon Setters have a slightly shorter lifespan of 10-12 years. Both breeds age gracefully with proper care.
  • As they get older, both Setters may develop arthritis. Regular, low-impact exercise helps maintain joint health. Adjust their diet as they age to prevent weight gain.
  • Gordon Setters might slow down earlier than Irish Setters. They may need more rest and gentler exercise routines in their senior years.
  • Regular dental care is crucial for both breeds throughout their lives. It prevents gum disease and helps them eat comfortably as they age.